A Bibliometric Exploration into the Global Research Impact of China’s Thousand Talents Brand
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32674/jcihe.v14i5.4581Keywords:
bibliometrics, China, research and development, global mobilityAbstract
The Thousand Talents Plan was an ambitious government initiative to repatriate and/or recruit experts from the global Chinese diaspora, along with some non-Chinese experts, with generous research funding and relocation packages. The plan has received much criticism from abroad, accusing endeavors of taking advantage of the open international education sector and facilitating espionage. While the Thousand Talents Plan received much of the attention, there are reportedly over 200 talent recruitment plans implemented by the Chinese government. We refer to these Talents Plans broadly as the Thousand Talents Brand (TTB), due to the diverse subjects, various programs, and a disparate number of the plans. Given the scrutiny and haphazardness of these initiatives, it has been difficult to gauge the impact on the global landscape of higher education, as official data on the broader project has not been readily available. Using bibliometric analysis of Web of Science, we find that research with funding from the TTB did decrease following the recent outcry, but was only roughly 1% of all Chinese research output at its peak in 2018. We find that the research was mostly concentrated in the hard sciences, with relatively little in the social sciences. Our results show the research funded through the initiatives was most commonly partnered with researchers in the Western powers, such as the US, Germany, and England, including connections to institutions with national security concerns like the US Department of Energy. While the findings do illustrate a complex web of global research governance through international partnerships, they cannot alleviate concerns that the TTB programs are potentially malign to sensitive sectors.
References
Allen, R., & Bista, K. (2022). Talented, Yet Seen with Suspicion: Surveillance of International Students and Scholars in the United States. Journal of International Students, 12(1).
Allen, R. M. (2021). Commensuration of the globalised higher education sector: how university rankings act as a credential for world-class status in China. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 51(6), 920-938.
Allen, R. M. (2021). Adding an international lens to the university striving model: How both global and national indicators influence the Chinese higher education hierarchy. International Journal of Chinese Education, 10(1), 22125868211006201.
Allen, R. M. (2017). A comparison of China’s “Ivy League” to other peer groupings through global university rankings. Journal of Studies in International Education, 21(5), 395-411.
Allen, R., & Ye, Y. (2021). Why Deteriorating Relations, Xenophobia, and Safety Concerns Will Deter Chinese International Student Mobility to the United States. Journal of International Students, 11(2), i-vii.
Allen, Y. L., & Zhang, W. (2021). Rural-Urban Satisfaction Towards China’s Public Goods and Services Provision. In Rural–Urban Dichotomies and Spatial Development in Asia (pp. 71-89). Springer, Singapore.
Altbach, P. G. (2016). Chinese higher education: “Glass ceiling” and “feet of clay”. International Higher Education, (86), 11-13.
Cantwell, B., & Grimm, A. (2018). The geopolitics of academic science. In Handbook on the politics of higher education. Edward Elgar Publishing.
Chan, R. Y., Bista, K., & Allen, R. M. (Eds.). (2021). Online teaching and learning in higher education during COVID-19: International perspectives and experiences. Routledge.
Chou, C. P. (2014). The SSCI syndrome in higher education: A local or global phenomenon. Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense Publishers.
Dyer, O. (2020). US cancer centre leaders secretly worked for China, internal report finds. BMJ: British Medical Journal (Online), 368.
Gao, Y., Jin, B., Shen, W., Sinko, P. J., Xie, X., Zhang, H., & Jia, L. (2016). China and the United States—global partners, competitors and collaborators in nanotechnology development. Nanomedicine: Nanotechnology, Biology and Medicine, 12(1), 13-19.
Gao, J., & Li, C. (2020). Version 2.0 of Building World-Class Universities in China: Initial Outcomes and Problems of the Double World-Class Project. Higher Education Policy, 1-17.
Hannas, W. C., & Tatlow, D. K. (2020). Chinese Technology Transfer—an introduction. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 3-20). Routledge.
Hayhoe, R., & Zha, Q. (2004). Becoming world-class: Chinese universities facing globalization and internationalization. Harvard China Review, 5(1), 87-92.
Joske, A. (2019). The China Defence Universities Tracker. Australian Strategic Policy Institute. November, 25.
Fedasiuk, R., & Felgoise, J. (2020). The Youth Thousand Talents Plan and China's Military. Center for Security and Emerging Technology.
Horta, H., & Shen, W. (2020). Current and future challenges of the Chinese research system. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, 42(2), 157-177.
Joske, A. & Stoff, J. (2020). The United Front and Technology Transfer. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 258-274). Routledge.
Joske, A. (2020). China’s Talent Programs. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 38-54). Routledge.
Kania, E. and Wood, P. (2020). The People’s Liberation Army and Foreign Technology. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 225-240). Routledge.
Keen, C. (2021). Academic Espionage: How International Trade Law Can Protect Higher Education. Georgia Journal of International & Comparative Law, 49(1), 211.
Kenderdine, T. (2017). How Can China Afford its Science and Technology Goals” East Asian Forum. Link: http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2017/10/13/how-can-china-afford-its-science-and-technology-goals/
Kennedy, A. B., & Dwyer, D. L. (2020). The stakes in decoupling discovery: China’s role in transnational innovation. The Pacific Review, 1-25.
Kim, B. G., & Kim, I. S. (2020). A Study on Policies of Chinese Overseas Talents and Entrepreneurial Activities in Distribution Industry. The Journal of Distribution Science, 18(11), 79-90.
Kim, H., and R. M. Allen. 2018. Glocalizing Cures for China’s Brain Drain Ills: The Thousand Talents Plan in Shanghai, Tianjin, and Guangdong. International Journal of Comparative Education and Development. 20 (1): 16–32.
Kwiek, M. (2021). What large-scale publication and citation data tell us about international research collaboration in Europe: Changing national patterns in global contexts. Studies in Higher Education, 46(12), 2629-2649.
Lee, J.J. & Haupt, J.P. (2020). Winners and Losers in U.S.-China Scientific Research Collaborations. Higher Education, 80, 57-74.
Lee, J. J., & Haupt, J. P. (2021a). Scientific collaboration on COVID-19 amidst geopolitical tensions between the US and China. The Journal of Higher Education, 92(2), 303-329.
Li, S. Q. (2020). The End of Publish or Perish? China's New Policy on Research Evaluation. Max Planck Institute for the History of Science.
Li, J., & Xue, E. (2021). Returnee faculty responses to internationalizing “academic ecology” for creating world-class universities in China’s elite universities. Higher Education, 81(5), 1063-1078.
Liu, J. M. (2021). From “Sea Turtles” to “Grassroots Ambassadors”: The Chinese Politics of Outbound Student Migration. International Migration Review, 01979183211046572.
Liu, W., Hu, G., Tang, L., & Wang, Y. (2015). China's global growth in social science research: Uncovering evidence from bibliometric analyses of SSCI publications (1978–2013). Journal of informetrics, 9(3), 555-569.
Lo, W. Y. W. (2011). Soft power, university rankings and knowledge production: Distinctions between hegemony and self‐determination in higher education. Comparative Education, 47(2), 209-222.
Lo W. Y. W. & Allen R. M. (2022) The Rankings Game. In D. Kapur, L. Kong, & D. Malone (Eds.), Oxford Handbook on Higher Education in Asia. Oxford UK: Oxford University Press.
Marginson, S., & Yang, L. (2021). Individual and collective outcomes of higher education: a comparison of Anglo-American and Chinese approaches. Globalisation, Societies and Education, 1-31.
Marginson, S. (2021). Global science and national comparisons: beyond bibliometrics and scientometrics. Comparative Education, 1-22.
Miao, L., Zheng, J., Jean, J. A., & Lu, Y. (2021). China’s International Talent Policy (ITP): The Changes and Driving Forces, 1978-2020. Journal of Contemporary China, 1-18.
Rezaei, S., & Mouritzen, M. R. (2021). Talent flowscapes and circular mobility in a Belt and Road (BRI) perspective-Global talent flows revisited. Asian Journal of Social Science.
Sheehan, M. (2019). The Transpacific Experiment: How China and California Collaborate and Compete for Our Future. Catapult.
Shen, W., & Jiang, J. (2021). Institutional prestige, academic supervision and research productivity of international PhD students: Evidence from Chinese returnees. Journal of Sociology, 14407833211055225.
Spears, A. (2020). Serve the Motherland while Working Overseas. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 21-37). Routledge.
Stoff, J. (2020). Sino-Foreign Research Collaboration. In W. C Hannas & D. K. Tatlow (Eds.), China's Quest for Foreign Technology Beyond Espionage (pp. 169-185). Routledge.
Sun, Y., & Cao, C. (2021). Planning for science: China’s “grand experiment” and global implications. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 8(1), 1-9.
Tollefson, J. (2019). Chinese American scientists uneasy amid crackdown on foreign influence. Nature, 570(7759), 13-15.
Tian, M., Y. Su, and X. Ru. 2016. “Perish or Publish in China: Pressures on Young Chinese Scholars to Publish in Internationally Indexed Journals.” Publications. 4(2): 9. doi:10.3390/ publications4020009.
Tillman, B. T. (2020). Red Scare or Red Herring: How the" China Initiative" Strategy for Non-Traditional Collectors Is Stifling Innovation in the United States. Seattle J. Tech. Envtl. & Innovation L., 11, 133
Zhu, J. (2019). The Composition and Evolution of China’s High-Level Talent Programs in Higher Education. ECNU Review of Education, 2(1), 104-110.
Zweig, D., & Wang, H. (2013). Can China bring back the best? The Communist Party organizes China's search for talent. The China Quarterly, 215, 590-615.
Zweig, D., & Kang, S. (2020). America Challenges China’s National Talent Programs. Report. CSIS. May, 5.
Zweig, D., Siqin, K., & Huiyao, W. (2020). ‘The Best are yet to Come:’ State Programs, Domestic Resistance and Reverse Migration of High-level Talent to China. Journal of Contemporary China, 29 (125), 776-791.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2022 Journal of Comparative & International Higher Education
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
The findings, interpretations, conclusions, and views expressed in Journal of Comparative and International Higher Education (JCIHE) are entirely those of the authors and should not be attributed in any manner to CIES, HESIG, or the sponsoring universities of the Editorial Staff. These works are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 License. Readers are free to copy, display, and distribute articles that appear in JCIHE as long as the work is attributed to the author(s) and JCIHE, it is distributed for non-commercial purposes only, and no alteration or transformation is made in the work. All other uses must be approved by the author(s) or JCIHE. By submitting a manuscript, authors agree to transfer without charge the following rights to JCIHE upon acceptance of the manuscript: first worldwide serial publication rights and the right for JCIHE to grant permissions as its editors judge appropriate for the redistribution of the article, its abstract, and metadata associated with the article in professional indexing and reference services.
